Compare
Arcade1Up vs AtGames Legends
Fourteen games you know against hundreds you mostly do not. The right answer depends on what a cabinet is for in your house.
How these picks were made: from published manufacturer specifications, governing-body standards and the room arithmetic - not from first-hand use. We have not played on these tables. Read the method.
Two different products
These are usually compared as competitors and they are better understood as different categories. One is a jukebox: a small set of known titles, immediately playable, with controls matched to them. The other is a platform: a large library, menus, add-on services, and the expectation that you will browse.
| Curated licensed cabinet | Platform cabinet | |
|---|---|---|
| Library size | ~14 titles | Hundreds, plus add-ons |
| Titles you recognize | All of them | A minority |
| Setup | Plug in and play | Some configuration |
| Menus | Minimal | Substantial |
| Emulation consistency | Consistent across a small set | Varies across a large set |
| Controls | Matched to its titles | General purpose, plus trackball |
| Grows over time | Barely | Yes |
| Best for | Guests and casual play | One enthusiast exploring |
Quick picks
| # | Product | Best for | Format | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Arcade1Up PAC-MAN Deluxe Arcade Machine | The curated answer | 14 games, 17 in LCD | |
| 2 |  AtGames Legends Ultimate Home Arcade Machine | The platform answer | Large library, trackball | |
| 3 |  Arcade1Up Mortal Kombat II Deluxe Arcade Machine | A specific genre | Fighting controls, 14 games |
A cabinet for each answer
#1 · The curated answer
Arcade1Up PAC-MAN Deluxe Arcade Machine
Listed at 5 ft tall with a 17-inch LCD, 14 games and WiFi leaderboards. The mainstream home cabinet.
Fourteen licensed titles, properly presented, on a 5-foot cabinet. If the cabinet exists so that people walk up and immediately play something they recognize, this is it.
- What works
- Immediate, no setup, no menus to learn
- Control layout matched to its games
- What does not
- Library does not grow much
#2 · The platform answer
AtGames Legends Ultimate Home Arcade Machine
A full-height cabinet with a large built-in library, add-on streaming and a trackball. The platform cabinet rather than the nostalgia cabinet.
A much larger built-in library plus add-on services and a trackball. This is a platform you explore rather than a jukebox you walk up to.
- What works
- Breadth, and it keeps growing
- Trackball covers a genre the others cannot
- What does not
- Emulation quality varies
- More menus between you and a game
#3 · A specific genre
Arcade1Up Mortal Kombat II Deluxe Arcade Machine
A full-height Deluxe cabinet with fighting-game controls and 14 titles. The Deluxe line is the taller, heavier one — measure the ceiling.
When you know exactly which games the cabinet is for, a genre cabinet beats a general one.
- What works
- Controls built for the genre
- What does not
- Narrow by design
Where they are similar
- Footprint. Both are roughly 2 feet by 2 feet of floor at full height.
- Build weight. Both are substantially lighter than an original arcade machine, and both feel it when you lean on them.
- Height. Both reach 5 feet 9 inches to 6 feet with a riser, which is the measurement to check against your ceiling.
- Power. Both run from a standard outlet with a short cord.
- Upgradability. Both have active communities modifying controls and internals, which is worth knowing if that appeals.
What actually decides it for most people
The specific games. A cabinet with the four games you have genuinely wanted since you were twelve will get played every week. A cabinet with four hundred games including those four will get played about as often, after some browsing. If a particular title matters to you, let that choose the cabinet - the rest of the comparison is secondary.
How this was assessed
On published library sizes, control components, cabinet dimensions and the structure of each product's software. We have not played these cabinets, and emulation quality claims here are limited to what each maker publishes.
